Thursday, February 26, 2009

Anything Indian works for us??

The recent melodrama after the success of Slumdog Millionaire forced me to ask this question to myself. What was so "Indiansih" about the movie that it won so many accolades in India before and after winning eight Oscars. It was not for the first time that A R Rahaman took an international project. If we forget A R Rahaman and Gulzar and the small role that Anil Kapoor played in the movie, there wasn't any other contribution made by an Indian in this movie. All the crew members in the movie were non Indian. So then, why such a big fuss? It won Oscars just like any other good movie would have done. Definitely Slumdog is not an exception, when Hollywood went offshore to pick up a theme. I can say this with much conviction because I have watched the movies Blood Diamond and The Last King of Scotland.


Indians love hero worship. From Team India players to Bollywood stars to politicians, we are known to put heroes up there. And in a country of a billion-plus, what does one do when one falls short of heroes? Do we outsource them or appropriate anybody remotely Indian? The celebration in India over Bobby Jindal’s elevation as Louisiana Governor proves again that whenever, anywhere, round the globe, we smell Indian we begin following the trails like sniff dogs. Even as his village and the rest of India broke into a jig over his political ascent in the US, very few realized that here was a man who had never even visited India. Mother Teresa born in Macedonia, distressed with the poverty stricken India, claimed us as her (too big!!) foster child. We claimed her as our own and one may argue, that she, too, had lovingly claimed us as her own. Then V S Naipaul created waves in the literary circuit and we went all out to embrace him. When NASA astronaut Sunita Williams, born to an Indian father, went into space, we were one of the first to go to town about her victory leap. We prayed day and night for her safe return. Not that we did any wrong praying for her. But we prayed for her considering her an Indian. Tell me is she really more Indian than American?

Do we as Indians tend to borrow role models because we don’t have enough of our own? Or are Bobby, Sunita, etc really our heroes and we are just doing what suits us best - hero worship?

9 comments:

Deven said...

hmmm...seems to be very correct

Vivek said...

Hi Parul,
I m agreee with u'r thoughts. but it's not the problem of indians, that we couldn't get oscar before "SD-M". In my opinion there may be two reasons :
1. There was lake of efforts
or
2. Monopoly of hollywood.
I have lot of things to say, so will keep comment on your topic
Bye
TC

Puneet Sahalot said...

brilliant....
I completely agree with ur views...
You write so well n I suggest you to try for some local dailies... It would be a good xperience for u.
One thing which I have notice abt not winning the Oscar Award by other Indian Movies is that in Two of the Movies, namely, "Mother India" n "Lagaan" the theme was against the Britishers.... that might have been a reason for "NOT WINNING" rather that "LOSING".

At last I would again suggest you to try in some local dailies. You articles are worth being published.

Swabhiman said...

... the INDIAN link has overtly fascinated the masses in the most indigenous way......... couldn't agree wuth you more..!
........ very wRitely said!!

mani said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
mani said...

The aim of life is to be happy and make others too (its more of the same thing as u can't b happy unless your surrounding is). Indians have a tradition of finding happiness in small small things unlike the dollar driven American culture. Music by A.R. rahman is a gud enough reason fr us to celebrate so is the little Indian connection of Sunita Williams.It may seem a bit strange to an American or a mind governed by American thoughts and culture.........but apne ko kya, apna funda, jiyo aur jine do, khush raho aur rahne do. If a woman(i mean sunita)gets the love of 100 million janta, i don't think she is ever gonna complain and the same applies to the crew of slumdog millionaire. I feel its always better to be happy than think over ki iss chij se mujhe (as an indian)happy hona chahie ya nahi ??

Vyom said...

One of the reasons abt the hipe given to the movie could b bcoz i feel that "Indians love to see themselves ( India or Indians ) on the Big Screens of the foreign cinema better known as hollywood, i personally feel they call it a better shot !!!!!

its not that India lacks heroes but the thing is we dnt recognize them unless they get a fame outside India...person may be not so famous in here but the moment he gets a shot outside...BANG !!!

nice topic to write upon...and very well written :)

Shamikh Faraz said...

nice article

Apoorv Bapat said...

brilliant post....

I would just like to add.

That India has millions of unsung heroes, there are hundreds of them who have suffered and succeded. India need real heroes and an equally responsible media to project these heroes. We too can play a big part, by worshipping real heroes, that some stupid stars....

In all, i must say, a very well written article...
@puneet i totally agree with you....